Summary
- In a crisis focus on where there is indiscriminate selling by market participants.
- Merger arbitrageurs have been forced sellers in the last fortnight which has caused market dislocation.
- Tiffany presents an attractive arbitrage opportunity.
Bear Markets are Challenging but Offer Opportunities
How to allocate capital right now is an important consideration. The market is likely to remain volatile in coming weeks and a V-shaped recovery is unlikely. The market appears to be a discounting a mild recession but there is every chance it could be sharper and more severe as economic activity grounds to a standstill for an extended period. As such, the playbook I am using is to take advantage of current market dislocations. Focusing on arbitrage opportunities could be especially rewarding should the window to acquire strong businesses at below intrinsic value be open for an extended period. My plan is to capitalise on near-term market inefficiencies that the market is presenting and invest the proceeds in high quality businesses for the long-term.
Merger Arbitrage Just Got a Lot More Interesting
The area which currently presents some of the most attractive opportunities is merger arbitrage. Ordinarily, this is the domain of institutional investors who grind out 3-5% unlevered returns per annum for their investors by arbitraging merger spreads. Many such investors use high levels of leverage to boost returns.
It is important to emphasise that as a strategy, merger arbitrage carries a negative return asymmetry When a deal does break, losses can be material as deals are often crowded with arbitrageurs all seeking to exit a position which no longer offers a hard catalyst.
On Monday 15 March, we started to see real market dislocation. There were reports that Millennium, one of the world’s largest hedge funds, had cut two of their five merger desks after breaching loss limits. Since then, we have seen systematic events funds – often geared as much as 6-8x – trigger margin calls from brokers and forced to de-leverage. As volatility across core M&A positions spiked, traditional merger arbitrageurs suffer draw-downs and are forced to cut position sizes and reduce gross exposure. This mass unwind has created some of the most attractive merger arbitrage spreads we have seen in decades.
Prior to the onset of the corona virus crisis, merger arbitrage spreads traded as tight as 0.5%. Since the crisis spread outside of China and became a global phenomenon, it has started to wreak havoc on global capital markets. Companies subject to announced mergers and acquisitions have not been spared. One of the safest announced deals is LVMH’s acquisition of Tiffany (TIF). Shares in Tiffany offer an attractive 10% spread to the offer price by LVMH of $135.00. To put this in perspective, the shares were trading at a tight 1.3% discount to the offer price as early as 3 March and have since reached spreads as wide as 22% on 18 March.

